A strip of film can hold more than one captured moment of time. There is the moment caught in the image, but there is also the later life of the strip itself, which may be stored in poor conditions, passed between people or physically altered. These later events settle over what was filmed and processed first. Looking at works by Melissa Friedling and Jennifer West, I argue that animation turns these material changes into another moving image, bringing the strip’s physical history into contact with the images it carries. What we see can suggest that history, although it cannot explain every encounter that has left a mark.
Laura U. Marks’s account of ‘haptic visuality’ offers a way of understanding how we encounter these surfaces. Haptic looking draws the eye towards texture and detail, encouraging us to explore an image rather than immediately recognise the objects or space it depicts. The eye begins to behave almost like touch, with perception shaped by bodily memory and cultural experience. However, this does not mean that physically touching film necessarily produces a haptic image. Marks distinguishes the texture of the medium from the way an image encourages us to look, noting that scratching the emulsion does not necessarily make a film appear tactile (2000, 173).
Here, I extend the application of haptic visuality by examining the relationship between the strip’s production history, its later material alterations and the experience of viewing the resulting images. I use tactility to describe physical contact with the strip, while haptic visuality describes a possible experience of viewing it. This distinction makes haptic visuality useful for understanding how marks invite bodily associations, while recognising its limits as an account of how those marks were made. Animation gives them duration and movement, but the relationship between the touch that happened and the touch we imagine remains uncertain.
Melissa Friedling’s work offers an example of this relationship through her exploration of found media and the histories embedded within it. Her short experimental documentary Garden Roll Bounce Parking Lot (2010) brings together two children’s memories of a Brooklyn garden and fragments of film once used to support its plants. A Bangladeshi family had woven 35mm film into the garden’s overhead lattice.
The strip came from Roll Bounce (2005), a commercial comedy drama directed by Malcolm D. Lee, in which the closure of a local roller rink called The Gardens sets the story in motion. Friedling recovered fragments left in the street after the garden was cut down and optically printed them, returning the images to the screen. A film about losing a gathering place had become part of another place that would also disappear.
Fig. 1. A strip of 35mm film woven into a garden trellis in Melissa Friedling’s Garden Roll Bounce Parking Lot (2010). Film still © Melissa Friedling; screenshot from Vimeo.
The opening live-action recording presents the strip as a physical object, something that occupies space and can be handled. When the recovered frames are returned to movement, we encounter the material differently. We can look into the photographed scene while also noticing the surface that interrupts it. The strip moves between being an object in the world and a carrier of another world.
I understand animation here through this activation of differences between frames. The damage is no longer available only for inspection on a length of film, it becomes a changing visual presence. The movement recorded in Roll Bounce continues beneath the interruptions of the altered surface. These two kinds of change belong to different moments, one to the original filming and the other to the strip’s subsequent life, but they now share the screen.
This is where haptic visuality becomes useful to the analysis. When damage interrupts recognition, our attention can move from the depicted scene towards the image’s surface. We begin looking across the marks rather than simply through them. Yet that experience cannot tell us that the strip supported a garden. The children’s recollections and the history of its recovery make the marks meaningful in relation to a particular family and place. Film’s physical “memory” is therefore partial. The strip retains changes caused by its passage through the world, but it does not preserve a complete account of what happened. Animation makes those changes perceptible over time, while the documentary gives them a social history. Together, they allow the material’s deterioration to become part of remembering the garden.
Los Angeles-based artist Jennifer West approaches this relationship through physical interventions ranging from bodily gestures to tool-mediated manipulations of the filmstrip. In Jam Licking & Sledgehammered Film (2008), performers licked and struck 70mm clear leader covered with jam, jelly and marmalade. The work restaged elements of Allan Kaprow’s Household, replacing the car used in the earlier happening with film material. West describes the resulting image as a ‘licked sunset’, with the leader stained orange, red and purple (Latimer 2011). The extended title connects the abstract image to the materials and actions that produced it, sustaining the space between reading about the performance and viewing its traces that West identifies as central to her work (Latimer 2011).
Here, direct animation makes the treated strip itself the source of the moving image. The performers’ actions are not presented as a continuous photographic record; rather, differences along the leader turn into visible changes across the screen. The time spent licking and striking the film is translated into a different duration, determined by the passage of the material through playback. We encounter the aftermath of the performance as animated movement. The phrase ‘licked sunset’ captures the ambiguity of this translation. Colour can suggest a landscape even though the work was produced through contact with a strip.
Knowing how it was made may also encourage us to imagine taste, pressure or stickiness. These sensations are not physically available to the viewer, but the account of production gives us another way to approach what we see. I read the film’s haptic potential through this movement between visual uncertainty and imagined sensation. Its physical production does not guarantee haptic viewing, but the changing colour gives the eye a surface to explore, while the title invites bodily associations.
Applying Marks’s concept to direct animation therefore requires attention to how contact becomes an image. A touched strip and a viewer’s sense of touch are connected through several transformations, rather than being interchangeable. Without this distinction, physical marks can be read as easy evidence of authenticity, as though the presence of touch alone explains the work. In Friedling’s film, that would risk reducing the garden’s history to an attractive damaged surface. In West’s, it would risk treating the image as a transparent record of the performance. Both works ask us to attend to what survives materially and what must be supplied through stories, titles and recollection.
Animation brings these surviving traces into time without restoring the events that produced them. Friedling’s recovered footage holds the original scene and the strip’s later deterioration together, while West turns the residues of a performance into changing colour. In each case, movement allows the material’s history to become part of the image. What the film remembers is therefore not only the scene once placed upon it, but its own passage through the world, with some encounters still visible and others beyond the image’s reach.
References:
Friedling, Melissa. 2010. Garden Roll Bounce Parking Lot. 16mm, colour, sound, 5 min.
Latimer, Quinn. 2011. ‘The Film Looks Like a Licked Sunset: A Conversation with Jennifer West.’ East of Borneo, 3 March.
Lee, Malcolm D., dir. 2005. Roll Bounce. Feature film.
Marks, Laura U. 2000. The Skin of the Film: Intercultural Cinema, Embodiment, and the Senses. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
West, Jennifer. 2008. Jam Licking & Sledgehammered Film. 70mm film transferred to video, colour, 3 min. 17 sec.
Grace Brennan is an animation researcher, educator, and practitioner whose work examines tactile image-making, material process, and the cultural significance of animation. She is Subject Leader in Digital Media Arts at the University for the Creative Arts and the Institute of Creativity and Innovation at Xiamen University, China. Her research considers analogue and digital animation, embodied knowledge, experimental practice, and pedagogy.

